• Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • flickr
  • blogger
  • youtube

blog-logo

  • Home
  • UAE Armenians
  • Hrach Kalsahakian
  • Հայերեն բաժին
  • Archives
    • News
    • Articles
    • Directory

Mind your own business, France

October 21, 2006
A+ A-
Email Print

 


By Suat Kiniklioglu


 


ANKARA Turkey is in an uproar. Turks are reacting bitterly to the tactlessness of the French National Assembly in passing a bill that would criminalize “denial” of the Armenian “genocide.”


 


Foreign Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy of France is right: The vote is seen as an unfriendly gesture by a vast majority of the Turkish people. We are dismayed by the ease with which French lawmakers seem willing to jeopardize relations between France and Turkey dating from the 16th century.


 


What puzzles us even more is that of all countries, France – seen by us as the symbol of civil liberties and free speech – would become hostage to a small, if influential, lobby that exploits every electoral opportunity to advance its narrow agenda.


 


Lawmakers are not historians and their attempt to establish facts about an extremely sensitive and complicated historic event is misguided at best. Further, the proposed bill represents a blow to freedom of expression at a time when European Union member states regularly lecture Ankara on legislation they view as curtailing free speech.


 


Both on grounds of substance and process, the National Assembly's action is deeply offensive and counterproductive. That is why the EU enlargement commissioner, Olli Rehn, and 16 prominent French historians opposed the bill.


 


Many Turks interpret the National Assembly's action as not just an attempt to appease an active lobby, but also as a populist appeal to the majority of the French public opposed to Turkish membership in the European Union.


 


In the run-up to what promises to be a very competitive presidential race next spring, both the French left and right seem ill disposed toward a predominantly Muslim country interested in EU membership.


 


Bound legally by the EU Council's decision to start accession negotiations with Turkey, French lawmakers may hope to provoke an already unsettled Turkey to quit the negotiations by touching a sensitive nerve. Whether such irresponsible behavior hinders efforts to heal the wounds of World War I and the tragedy of Ottoman Armenians seems to be lost on them.


 


Ironically, this ill-considered action comes at a time when Turkey's domestic debate on the Armenian issue is more open than at any time in the past. Turks on both sides of the issue are intensely discussing what happened in 1915-1916 and whether it can be defined as genocide.


 


Last year, in an unprecedented move, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan suggested that Turkey and Armenia set up a joint commission of historians to determine whether the events of 1915-1916 constituted genocide. The offer was rejected by Armenia. Turkey also organized its first international conference on the Armenian issue with Armenian historians last year. Furthermore, Turkey's determination to join the EU provides ongoing impetus for this healthy process of reconciliation to continue.


 


Turkish-Armenian reconciliation cannot be facilitated by laws passed in foreign parliaments. Such moves only help those who thrive on the continuation of the impasse between Turks and Armenians.


 


As tempting as gesture politics may be for French politicians, any genuine effort at reconciliation must be based on the recognition that both Armenians and Turks suffered immensely during the fateful years of World War I. To move forward, the focus must be broadened to include common losses and experiences during this period, rather than limited to the question of whether the events of 1915-1916 can be qualified as genocide. Context is critical.


 


Having Turkey as a member in the EU is both in Europe's and Armenia's interest. Provoking Turkey on a sensitive issue only serves to further alienate a country whose destiny will have a major impact on the greater Europe of which Armenia is also part.


 


As the British Armenian historian Ara Sarafian eloquently noted, the ultimate irony is that France, which has not faced up to its own genocidal past, dares to pass legislation on Turkey's past.


 


Thankfully our lawmakers are unlikely to follow that path. After all, we want to remain true to the ideals of Rousseau, Voltaire and the French encyclopedists who inspired us and the European Enlightenment.


 


Source: International Herald Tribune, October 19, 2006


http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/10/19/opinion/edkinik.php


 


Suat Kiniklioglu is director of the Ankara office of the German Marshall Fund of the United States.

author-avatar

Posted by Azad-Hye

Like to share?

Social Media

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • flickr
  • blogger
  • youtube
Newer PostRestoring the orthography of the Armenian nation
Older PostArmenia in the International Olympiad in Informatics

POPULAR

item-thumbnail

Rebecca Malikian’s novel “The Caravan of Death”

July 10, 2015
item-thumbnail

Erebouni pen launched in Dubai and other cities

April 12, 2015
item-thumbnail

Vardavar (water pouring) international festival in Armenia gains popularity

July 17, 2015
item-thumbnail

Essam Nagy’s documentary “In The Beginning Was Armenia” (Interview)

January 11, 2020
item-thumbnail

Anna Dolabjian: I feel life coaching as a dream coming true

January 18, 2018

LATEST

item-thumbnail

Liana Ghaltaghchyan is the new Managing Director at the Children of Armenia Fund

January 10, 2023
item-thumbnail

Indian Journalist Venkatesh Remakrishnan mentions the Armenians of Chennai

October 30, 2022
item-thumbnail

Renovation of the Ghukasavan Cultural Center’s main hall

December 1, 2021
item-thumbnail

Nobel Prize winner Ardem Patapoutian

October 7, 2021
item-thumbnail

Armenian Church of the Virgin Mary in Basra, Iraq

August 30, 2021

COMMENTS

Azad-Hye on In memory of AUB Medical Alumni who died during the First World War
Azad-Hye on Kessab Ousoumnasirats celebrates centennial
Lawrence Danny CPA on Kessab Ousoumnasirats celebrates centennial
Stephensmith on Pizza making vending machine invented by Puzant Khachadourian
ALEXANIAN on Astghik Voskerchyan: Every element in my environment has a role in my creations

Categories

  • Applications
  • Art
  • Books
  • Business
  • Celebrations
  • Chinese Armenians
  • Courses and Camps
  • Cyprus Armenians
  • Diaspora Armenians
  • Documentaries
  • Education
  • Egyptian Armenians
  • Energy
  • Ethiopian Armenians
  • European Armenians
  • Festivals
  • Genocide
  • History
  • Hrach Kalsahakian
  • Indian Armenians
  • Interviews
  • Iraqi Armenians
  • Language
  • Lebanese Armenians
  • Music
  • Poetry
  • Politics
  • Religion
  • Rural Armenia
  • Science
  • Syrian Armenians
  • Tourism
  • Turkish Armenians
  • UAE Armenians
  • Websites
  • Հայերեն բաժին

CUSTOM LINKS

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact

RANDOM POSTS

item-thumbnail

«ՔԱՅԼ ԴԵՊԻ ՏՈՒՆ» ծրագրի հյուրընկալ ընտանիքների համար նախատեսված հայտադիմում

item-thumbnail

Նախարարն ընդունեց Ալմելոյի քաղաքային խորհրդի պատգամավոր Ռոբին Հայկ Գելիջիի

item-thumbnail

Սփիւռքի Չորրորդ Իշխանութիւնը

TAG CLOUD

Armenian Art Armenian Catholics Armenian Christmas Armenian Costumes Armenian Genocide Armenian Songs Armenian Velvet Revolution Azad-Hye Celebrations Cyprus Armenians Daniel Varoujan Hejinian Diaspora Diaspora Armenians Education Emma Kant Emma Karapetyan Ethiopian Armenians Garni Geghard Genocide Goris Greece Hidden Armenians History Iraqi Armenians Kessab Kessabtzis Language Lebanese Armenians Meri Martirosyan Music Music Application Nana Aramyan Nikol Pashinyan Norway Ottoman Empire Paris Speech Therapy Syrian Armenians Syunik Turkey Turkish Armenians UAE Armenians Vardavar Western Armenia

Search this website

© 2023 Azad-Hye . Designed by Wpinhands
Scroll